It usually happens when a buyer calls the listing agent directly, or when two agents at the same brokerage end up on opposite sides of a deal. Because no one can fully advocate for both sides, the law treats it carefully: some states ban it, and others require informed, written consent from the buyer
How does dual agency work?
There are two common versions. In the first, one agent represents both the buyer and the seller. In the second, two agents at the same brokerage each work with one side, but because both clients belong to that brokerage, the brokerage itself is
Some states handle the second version through designated agency, where the broker assigns a separate agent to each side. Texas, for example, lets a brokerage act as an intermediary and appoint a different license holder to work with each party, but only with both
Where dual agency is allowed, the agent must tell both sides and get their consent before acting for both. The NAR Code of Ethics also requires full disclosure and the informed consent
What do you give up with a dual agent?
Advocacy. An agent with fiduciary duties owes loyalty to one client, so a dual agent has to stay neutral on what matters most. They can’t tell the seller how high the buyer will go, or tell the buyer how low the seller will accept, without permission. They also can’t push for one side
What usually remains is honesty, fair dealing, confidentiality and help with paperwork and deadlines. The exact list depends on your state and the consent
Some people like the single point of contact. Some buyers also hope a dual agent will lower the commission. That’s negotiable,
Is dual agency legal in every state?
No. Florida law, for example, says a licensee may not act as a disclosed or nondisclosed dual agent. Licensees there are presumed to be transaction brokers unless another relationship is set in writing. Other states allow dual agency with written consent, and some use different names
Your state’s agency disclosure form lays out the relationships allowed where you live. Read it before you share your budget, timeline or bottom
Should you agree to dual agency?
It depends on how much negotiating help you want. If the deal is simple and both sides already agree on price and terms, a neutral agent may be fine. If you expect hard negotiation, a home with known issues or several competing offers, your own
You can also say no. If you’re a buyer talking to the listing agent, ask to be referred to a separate buyer’s agent. If you’re a seller, your listing agreement should say whether you’ve agreed to dual
For questions about your state’s rules, ask your state real estate commission or a
Common mistakes
- Thinking a dual agent can quietly favor you. They owe the same limited duties
to both sides. - Assuming dual agency is allowed everywhere. Some states, including
Florida, prohibit it. - Signing a consent form without reading what the agent can
and can’t share. - Believing dual agency always means a lower fee. The fee is
negotiable either way.
Questions
Is dual agency bad for buyers?
Not always, but you lose an advocate. A dual agent can’t negotiate for you against the seller, so it works best when the terms are simple and both sides
What is the difference between dual agency and designated agency?
In dual agency, one agent or brokerage represents both sides without advocating for either. In designated agency, the brokerage assigns a separate agent to each side, and each one works for
Can I refuse dual agency?
Yes. Where it’s allowed, it requires your consent, and you can ask to work with a
Does an agent have to tell me they’re a dual agent?
Yes. Where it’s allowed, the agent must disclose it and get informed consent from both the buyer and the seller, and the NAR Code of Ethics requires the same of every Realtor.
Sources
- Florida Statutes § 475.278: Authorized brokerage relationships
- Texas Real Estate Commission: Information About Brokerage Services
- NAR: Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice
Written and checked by the Broker & Agent team on October 2, 2026. General information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Something out of date? Tell us.